Personal Finance Management : brief review

For last couple of months, I want to move to personal financial SW and I’m glad to  recommend yodlee money (web based). My criteria were
1. Sophisticated ,yet simple in terms of management
2. Ability to auto categorize transactions with minimal guidance
3. Easy Account setup
4. Ability to setup budgets
5. Gives me spending analysis in terms of pie charts and tables etc
6. Should be able to setup all accounts incl IRA/401K , Indian banks etc and manual real estate accounts.
7. Less expensive ( less than 30$ per yr)

With the above in mind, I tried
1. Quicken Premier deluxe 2008
2. Microsoft Money
3. wesabe (free web based)
4. mint.com (free web based)
5. yodlee (free web based)

Quicken is far too sophisticated and demands more attention/time. It cannot auto categorize all of the transactions correctly. But by far it has all the nuts and bolts if you have time ..Doesnt support Indian banks a/c . Formats supported are QFX/OFX only.

Microsoft Money also pretty much has the same features as quicken, but I didnt like the way setting up accounts , the look and feel, manageability of the accounts and SW itself.

Wesabe : You cannot setup indian bank accounts, cannot auto categorize the transactions, but gives you the ability to define the category names you want . Has best online community..it gives you tips on say groceries from other users in wesabe and if its applicable , you can implement. I didnt care for this feature as it was too generic in some cases and not for indians :) ..I dont care what mr.dude from Idaho has to say on the food and dining..For me this feature was not imp.. and big minus from my side was this doesnt have auto update feature….

mint.com : By far the it has the best UI ..you should check it out just for kicks..far better management and account setup than any…it still misses in auto categorizing some transactions correctly..Limited setup for Indian banks/overseas bank. shares the same infrastructure as yodlee for transactions retrival..this site has the ability to compare your spending in a particular category vs users in particular city avg spending..it also gives you tips on saving more money..for example, it can tell you that have  a checking a/c WAMU will save you an extra  50$ etc…

Yodlee: UI is not as great as mint, but better than wesabe. Supports most indian banks, some india pvt life & pension insurance accts (I expected that it would since , very minimal guidance is required for auto categorization and probably bets in class among all..you can track your airline rewards etc.. and it satifies all the 7 criteria I had and best of all its free …

for webbased finance management, all 3 of them use the same level of SSL encryption as many bank do and yodlee has extra layer of support for filtering phishing by asking you to identify a image and some extra questions you need to answer ..I think they are verisigned as well..so I’m least concerned abt security and if you want to avoid browser hijacks itself, use idvault and for firefox, use fijan secure browsing addon  + adblock plus addon + noscript addon

give it a shot ……

kiran

About kiran

Kiran Bulusu is an a strategic results-oriented field applications engineer and account management professional in Design Automation Industry with expertise in managing key accounts, developing strategic relation ships, pre & post sales campaigns and product management.
This entry was posted in Misc. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>